-Finnigan the Destroyer became the first King of Pain Champion when he defeated Sick Puppy in the finals of a tournament on 08.01.03 @ Friday Night FireFights!.
NOTE: The tournament also included Death's Head and Jackson Kelly.
-Death's Head d. Finnigan the Destroyer on 09.24.03 @ Kasakstock: Summer Inferno.
-EnFuego d. Death's Head on 10.15.03 @ a house show.
-Dylan Jones d. Enfuego @ a house show.
-Pete Hardy d. Dylan Jones @ a house show.
-Dan Sweeny d. Pete Hardy on 01.30.04 @ FireFights
NOTE: After Dan Sweeny won the match, CEO AJ came out and retired the King of Pain Championship. But he named Dan Sweeny #1 Contender for the newly reinstated US Championship